I'm supposed to post part two of the Aus vs. US cover battle but this has been bugging me lately so I have to ask for you guys opinions and advice. For the book bloggers who have different rating scales for each part of the books: plot, character, writing, ending, even cover, it might be a little bit easier...but for those who only have a sole scale, how could you manage to rate a book precisely? I mean, if you find a story somehow between a 3 star and a 3.5 star, which section will you put it into? Or suddenly a book you come across appears to be better than all of the 5 star ones, what will you do? Will you rerate everything you've reviewed? It sounds pretty ridiculous to me but I still want to give the readers the exact ideas of the books. I'm kinda clueless now :(
So what do you think? Have you experienced the same thing? Which actions did/will you take? Please share your thoughts!